Archive | death penalty

23 September 2010 ~ 3 Comments

Anthony Graves – Justice Denied?

TCADP has followed the Anthony Graves case for many years and remains concerned about his wrongful conviction.

In 2007, TCADP recognized University of St. Thomas Associate Professor of Communications Nicole Casarez and her students for their efforts to investigate Graves’ innocence claim and their contributions to the  overturning of his conviction.  Professor Caserez and her students were presented with an Appreciation Award during the 2007 TCADP Annual Conference.

Anthony Graves walked off of death row on September 6, 2006, with his conviction overturned by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.  The charges against him could have been dismissed after the federal court thoroughly discredited the testimony that had put him on death row.  But four years later, he still sits in a Burleson County jail awaiting a new trial with a $1 million bail.  His retrial is set to begin in February and the state once again intends to seek the death penalty.

Read the Texas Monthly article and decide for yourself:

Innocence LostTexas Monthly, October 2010 –

Editorial: Justice, Delayed and Denied” – Miami Herald, September 22, 2010

Editorial:  “Murder conviction chock full of holesDallas Morning News, September 15, 2010.

More info from TCADP on Anthony Graves (blog posts, print fact sheet)

Continue Reading

02 September 2010 ~ Comments Off on Gov. Commutes Death Sentence of Kevin Keith!

Gov. Commutes Death Sentence of Kevin Keith!

Great news!  Ohio Governor Ted Strickland has commuted the death sentence of Kevin Keith to life without parole.  Here’s an excerpt from his statement:

“… despite the evidence supporting his guilt and the substantial legal review of Mr. Keith’s conviction, many legitimate questions have been raised regarding the evidence in support of the conviction and the investigation which led to it.  In particular, Mr. Keith’s conviction relied upon the linking of certain eyewitness testimony with certain forensic evidence about which important questions have been raised.  I also find the absence of a full investigation of other credible suspects troubling.”

Read the entire statement.

Read more about Kevin Keith.

TCADP thanks everyone who contacted the Ohio Parole Board and Governor Strickland on behalf of Kevin Keith.  We’ll be in touch with any follow-up actions you can take.

Continue Reading

01 September 2010 ~ Comments Off on El Paso to Host Death Row Exonoree Juan Melendez

El Paso to Host Death Row Exonoree Juan Melendez

Death row survivor Juan Melendez will share his gut-wrenching story of wrongful conviction and ultimate exoneration with audiences throughout El Paso from September 25-27, 2010.   This bilingual tour is sponsored by El Pasoans Against the Death Penalty (EPADP), a chapter of the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty.

A native of Puerto Rico, Juan spent 17 years, 8 months, and 1 day on Florida’s death row for a crime he did not commit.  He was exonerated and released from death row on January 3, 2002 after the discovery of a long-forgotten transcript of a taped confession by the real killer.  No physical evidence ever linked Juan to the crime, and his conviction and death sentence hinged on the testimony of two questionable witnesses (one of those witnesses later recanted and the other is deceased).

Mr. Melendez will be visiting West Texas at a critical time, as concerns about the likely wrongful execution of Cameron Todd Willingham and ongoing exonerations continue to call into question the reliability and fairness of our state’s death penalty system. Since 1973, 138 people – including 11 Texans – have been exonerated from death rows nationwide due to evidence of their wrongful conviction.  Mr. Melendez is the 99th person on this list.

EPADP Coordinator Karen Peissinger-Venhaus writes: “We are very excited about Juan Melendez coming to El Paso for the ¡La Pena de Muerte No Mas! speaking tour!  In addition to hearing Juan’s compelling talk, attendees will have the opportunity to write a postcard to their Texas representative in support of death penalty repeal, and to register to vote.  Not only is this event a great outreach and education opportunity, it maintains the momentum towards repeal of the death penalty in Texas.”

All events are free and open to the public.  See the Tour Schedule and spread the word.

El Pasoans: There’s still time to schedule an event with your faith community, class, or civic group! Contact Karen at or 915-740-7076.  You can also support the tour with a generous donation to TCADP.

Continue Reading

01 September 2010 ~ 1 Comment

Death Penalty Issue Part of Respect Life Month in the Catholic Church

According to the Death Penalty Information Center and Catholics Against Capital Punishment, for the first time in recent years the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops’ annual Respect Life Program will urge participants to make opposition to the use of the death penalty a significant part of their efforts to carry out the Church’s pro-life teachings. The Respect Life Program takes place throughout the month of October.  In their 1980 Statement on Capital Punishment, the U.S. Bishops voiced their opposition to the death penalty and affirmed the Catholic Church’s belief in the sanctity of all human life.

The USCCB’s Secretariat for Pro-Life Activities has developed a packet of materials for parishes and other groups to use throughout the month.  These include articles on key issues, homily notes, intercessions, and a liturgy guide.  Materials are available in English and Spanish and can be downloaded from   TCADP urges all of its Catholic members to consider working within your parishes to organize an activity or program on the death penalty in October.  Please let us know how we can help your efforts!

Read an article from Kansas City – St. Joseph Bishop Robert W. Finn: “Divine Mercy and the Death Penalty,” which is part of the packet of materials.

Continue Reading

23 August 2010 ~ Comments Off on RESOURCES: New DPIC Podcast Explores Victims’ Families and the Death Penalty

RESOURCES: New DPIC Podcast Explores Victims’ Families and the Death Penalty

The latest edition of the Death Penalty Information Center’s series of podcasts, DPIC on the Issues, is now available for download. This podcast, Victims and the Death Penalty, explores the issues faced by murder victims’ families when capital punishment is being considered. Generally, this series of podcasts offers brief, informative discussions of key death penalty issues.  Other recent episodes include discussions on Representation and Race. Click here to download the latest episode of the podcast on Victims. You can also subscribe through iTunes to receive automatic updates when new episodes are posted and receive access to all eight episodes. Other audio and video resources can be found on DPIC’s Multimedia page.

(DPIC, Aug. 20, 2010).  See also Victims.

Continue Reading

18 August 2010 ~ Comments Off on Save the Date: Austin Panel Discussion

Save the Date: Austin Panel Discussion

On Tuesday, September 28th, 7 PM, at St. John’s United Methodist Church, 2140 Allandale Road, Austin there will be a panel discussion about capital punishment featuring three individuals who view it from very different and unique perspectives.

The panel members include:

Professor Rob Owen, UT Law School and Co-Director of the Capital Punishment Center. Rob has defended people facing the death penalty at every level of state and federal court system, including arguing successfully at the U.S. Supreme Court.

Reverend Sidney Hall, Senior Pastor, Trinity United Methodist Church, Austin. Rev. Hall leads a congregation that describes itself as inclusive and that is active in social justice issues.

Michael Heath, murder victim family. Michael brings a voice and perspective to the issue of capital punishment that answers the challenge, “…but what if it were your family member…?”

Please put this date on your calendar, invite  friends and plan to be with us for this interesting event.

For more info email

Continue Reading

02 August 2010 ~ 2 Comments

El Pasoans Against the Death Penalty – August 2010 Newsletter

Learn more about the El Paso TCADP chapter in their August newsletter.

The newsletter includes info on the Juan Melendez Speaking tour scheduled for September, upcoming events and more!

A link is found in the Chapter News section…

Continue Reading

30 July 2010 ~ 2 Comments

TX Forensic Science Commission Admits “Flaws” in Willingham Case

There has been a great deal of media coverage of the Texas Forensic Science Commission’s meeting last Friday, July 23, 2010, during which a subcommittee said that arson investigators in the case of Cameron Todd Willinghamused flawed science but were not negligent” in an investigation that led to his controversial 2004 execution.  According to CNN, “the panel declared that investigators were using the science available to them at the time, even though it was flawed.  The board said it would present its final report for a vote at a meeting in October.”  (CNN, “Texas state board says arson investigators used flawed science,” July 23, 2010).

According to the Dallas Morning News, “Texas Forensic Science Commission members said they believed there was insufficient evidence to establish whether investigators botched their 1991 investigation of the fire that killed Cameron Todd Willingham’s three daughters.”  This determination starkly contradicts nine fire experts who have examined the case since the original conviction and found that the evidence did not support the finding of arson.

State Senator Rodney Ellis (Houston) issued the following statement in response to the proceedings:

“I am happy to hear that the Forensic Science Commission is moving
forward on the Todd Willingham investigation, but unfortunately the
Commission is off track in terms of what it should be investigating.
It was painfully apparent that many FSC members believe that flawed
science was used in the Willingham conviction, but the FSC does not
seem interested in looking at the bigger picture: When did the State
Fire Marshal start using modern arson science and did the State Fire
Marshal commit professional negligence or misconduct when it failed to
inform the courts, prosecutors, the Board of Pardons and Parole, and
the Governor that flawed arson science had been used to convict
hundreds of defendants?…”

Here’s a sample of some of the editorials and columns that have appeared:

Dallas Morning News – “Official ‘oops’ in the Willingham case?”, July 26, 2010

Houston Chronicle – “Forensic panel must resist chair’s efforts at sabotage” by Barry Scheck and Patricia Willingham Cox, July 20, 2010

Austin American-Statesman – “Science – like death – has its limits“, July 27, 2010

Houston Chronicle, “Questions of Innocence,” July 28, 2010

Houston Chronicle, “Of science, witches and arson trials,” by Rick Casey, July 28, 2010

Read more.

Continue Reading